

Transcript
4,808 words · about 21 min readGenerated automatically from the audio, so it may contain errors. Tap a time to listen from there.
Okay, let’s get our Bible, and we’re going to cover one subject, and then we’re going to be, if you want to go ahead and turn, let me just do a quick review of what we want to cover. You can go to Ephesians chapter 5, and we’re going to be looking at Ephesians and Colossians here in just a little bit. We’ll not start there though. Just by way of review, as we’ve been talking about our church’s music and kind of explaining and laying the groundwork for the choices of music that we have here at our church, we have, last week we primarily concentrated on the assertion, the philosophy that music is amoral.
And we examined that claim. Again, we’re not trying to be exhaustive here, but what we’re trying to demonstrate is that some of the principles that are used that lead people to the conclusions and to the decisions in music that they choose, the principles themselves have to be examined. And one of those principles is, does music have a moral characteristic or not? And the assertion is that music does not.
And it goes, again, just very quickly reviewing, musical notes are not moral any more than a letter of the alphabet is moral or immoral. And so, therefore, you can’t say that any song, any tune is moral or immoral any more than you can say any note is moral or immoral. And that’s something that is, I think, worthy of rejection. In the same way that, yes, we acknowledge that letters of the alphabet, A is not any more moral than B.
Read the full transcriptShow less
But when you put them together, you can create morality or immorality, and so we’re going to take this principle, our examination of this principle to the next step today, and remembering that really when we talk about the question of morality of music, we’re not quibbling over philosophical principles here. That’s not what this is about. Most people don’t spend very much time quibbling over a philosophical point like this, whether music is moral or immoral.
It really is about a practical outcome, about our actual music choices and whether they’re right or wrong or good or bad. And so the point of this argument is not to establish the point itself, but to provide a justification for a later argument. And that is, since music is amoral, no one can say that one style of music is better or worse than any other style of music.
Any more than one can say that one letter of the alphabet is better or worse than any other letter of the alphabet. And the final destination is, since music is all moral, no one can say that rock or light rock or rap or hip-hop, country, pop, R &B, metal, or any other genre of music is better or worse than any other or can be forbidden or should be forbidden.
Or permitted or not permitted in church. Not even to mention our personal listening. And again I just want to reiterate that point. That our personal. The principles that govern the use of music in our church. Are the same principles in scripture. That govern our personal music choices. In other words the same ones, you’re not going to find anywhere in the Bible where it says, in church you should listen to this kind of music, and everywhere outside of church you should listen to that kind of music.
There’s only one set of principles, and it applies to all. These neat religious distinctions that we make, they’re nice and they’re cute, but they’re not really biblical. It’s just what the Bible says and you apply it to every area of life. And so that’s the real question with music being all moral. It’s really a question of, it lays the groundwork for allowing any and all kinds of music.
That’s the purpose, okay? And again, it is important that you understand how the argument is being used so that you know the destination, okay? So, now, so what we’re positing then, what I’m positing, is that music, maybe not a note, but music styles and tunes and things like that, when you put notes together, which is what music is, right? When you put it together, it does have a moral, there is a moral element to it, okay? In the same way you put letters together and you get words.
So, the primary reason it has a moral element to it is because music is not created in a vacuum. Every single one of us, and this is really a profound truth in my opinion, but it’s a truth that really I started to learn, our family, my wife and I started to learn in particular, going to the mission field where you’re immersed in a different culture. Because when you’re immersed in a different culture, when you’re in only one culture, it’s hard for you to see all the things that are affected by your culture.
It’s just innate. It’s just assumed. But when you go to another culture, you realize everything else, everything is assumed differently. Everything, including how you speak, your value system, family relationships, society relationships, to include music and how it’s understood and how it’s used. So knowing that in our society, every one of us was born into a society with a cultural context. Does everybody agree with that? Every one of us.
And the best example of that is every one of us, at least every one of us that was born in the United States in the American culture, because I know some people were born in other cultures and that has a different set of assumptions. But in the United States, if you’re born into the United States and you hear, as an example, you hear, and see, I don’t even have to explain it.
I don’t have to be technical about it. You hear a snare drum playing a certain tune and you automatically think of patriotic music, right? You hear a snare drum. Is that a sin? Well, no, it’s not a sin. You hear a snare drum or the big drum they carry in the marching band and you hear and it automatically takes your mind to a patriotic scene. Why? It’s a cultural association.
It’s a cultural association. All music has that. All cultures have that. Okay? We have to understand that. So when we talk about styles of music, whether it be the genres of music that I mentioned a minute ago, R &B, hip-hop, country, pop, all of these things, all of those are part of this culture that we live in. Now, it might not be a part that we deal with a lot, for instance, hip-hop, but each one of those styles carries with it a part of a broader culture.
And with that comes associations. And there is nothing you or I can do to change that. Our taking religious words and switching out the worldly words and the immoral words, and I’ll use kind of the most extreme example, hip hop or rap. And I know there’s Christian rap. I know that. But I’m going to use the most extreme example. No, let’s go even further. Heavy metal. There’s a such thing as heavy metal Christian music.
Do you know that? There is. Okay? Christian metal. But if you remove the words that are intended to be suicidal and demonic and devil worshiping, and you put Christian words in it, that does not change the association of the tune and style of the music from its cultural association. Nothing you can do changes that. Nothing. And that is true of every style of music that exists to include the kind that we use in our church because that is a style.
Now, the very fact that there are genres of music and you can categorize them tells us that these styles are associated with certain contexts and certain cultures. For instance, if you hear a country song, what does it relate to? It relates to pickup trucks and beer and cowboy boots and insert here. Now, I know it’s changed. Now, it’s becoming more pop-centered, but it’s associated with those things and there’s nothing, the sound.
I’m not talking about the words. I’m talking about the sound. Okay. And let me hasten to say, not all music that has associations is bad, just like I gave you the example with patriotic music. And even the country-sounding music, the country style is not always related to bad things. Sometimes it’s related to the country, right? Country life and stuff like that. So all the associations are not evil in every case.
Now I think there are some genres that you would be hard pressed to find any good thing, any good association whatsoever. But not all styles are like that. So we can’t simply borrow any style of music and make it Christian and do so and think we’re going to remove all the associations because we slap Christian words onto it. And that has been the argument forever. That is since the advent of contemporary Christian music, which itself is its own genre now.
But at the beginning, that was the argument. Well, this has Christian words and a Christian message, but that doesn’t change the association of it. The cultural associations are part of the style and they cannot be separated. And so someone, you’ve probably heard this, and I added this just kind of as a cutesy little thing, not that it makes a big difference, but I’ve heard people say in response to that, well, you know that Amazing Grace is a bar tune, right?
Has anybody ever heard that? And the implication of making that statement is, see, even the tune Amazing Grace is actually a tune that has associations with a bar. First of all, that’s on its face false, especially in our time. And so if we want to go back to when Amazing Grace, the tune to Amazing Grace, which was called New Britain, was written. It was first published in 1829.
It was not a bar tune. It was a folk melody. It was published in a book called Columbian Harmony in 1829. That’s when it first came out. The tune now, not the words. The words go back to the 1700s. John Newton. So first of all, that’s false on its face. But secondly, they’re actually proving the point. They’re actually proving the point. What is a bar tune? A bar tune is a tune that has an association with a bar, right?
And so by saying, see, Amazing Grace is a bar tune, the idea is, well, you can’t say we can’t have bar tunes in our church or in our whatever. See, Amazing Grace was a bar tune. That’s the argument. But you’re actually proving that it has associations. You’re admitting it. Even though it’s not even true. But here’s the thing. The associations and the cultural context of music and the styles of music is the point.
That’s the thing people want. In the seeker, we’ve already covered this before, but in the seeker-sensitive movement, the seeker-sensitive churches, the reason why they pick the music they pick for the seekers is because of the associations. So you can’t on one side deny that music styles have associations and therefore a moral character. And on the other side, use the associations to attract people that are drawn to that kind of music.
It’s either true or false. The truth is the reason that that kind of music is chosen for churches is because it appeals to what people refer to as the seekers, which I don’t think there are any, but that’s why it’s done. Oh, these people like pop, so we’re going to do pop style music. These people like R &B, so we’re going to do R &B. That’s the thinking.
Okay? And we read some quotes that demonstrate that. Now, because of these things, because music styles have associations in our culture, we must take into account those associations when we seek to use them for the glory of God. Because you cannot simply take a pen knife and divide them. You can’t. You can’t. Those associations will color the words and themes that are attached to our music. What are the associations of hip-hop and rap?
You know what it is? Thug life. Drugs, alcohol, and sex. And criminal activity. That is the associations of hip-hop. That has no association. That has no place being associated with our God whatsoever. And for someone to argue that those associations don’t matter and we can just commandeer that style and no one is going to make that association is lying. That is not true. Those think you cannot simply erase that.
What are the associations of rock? What are the associations of pop? Taylor Swift. She’s like a mega star, right? What are the associations? You can’t just simply, well, it doesn’t matter. Well, I beg to differ. It does matter. You and I don’t control that. No matter how much we plug our ears and say, well, we’re using it for Jesus. That does not change the association. You don’t get to choose that.
That’s something you were born into. We were born into that. Are those associations godly? We could go into country. We could go into metal. Or any of the more tame ones, like rock or whatever. Are those associations godly? Are those associations spiritual? It matters because those reflect upon the God that we’re using this music to worship. Now here’s the thing. This is where it cuts a little bit.
I think the associations are the reason why the music, knowing that music is in a way directly wired to our emotional part of us, I think the associations are the problem. Because many people, for many Christians, many Christians have a very hard time making a clean break with things in the world that are associated with evil. They do. Especially when that thing is hardwired to their heart.
Making a clean break from those associations is hard. Because you grew up with it. It’s associated with memories, sometimes good memories. I, to this day, my wife can bear witness, I, to this day, because my grandmother and my mother listen to country music all day, every day in the car. Whistle 100, 92.5. I mean, I know all the country songs from the 80s and 90s, not all of them, but many, many country songs in the 80s and 90s.
I know the tunes and I know all the lyrics by heart still to this day. I do. And to be honest, I hear it played and it’s like time machine. It’s a time machine. It brings back memories of, well, I won’t go into too much detail with what it makes me think of, but it does remind me of my grandmother, my mom, and when we would be in a car and all those kinds of things.
It reminds me of that. And you all know, as you get older, those nostalgic things get more important to you. So making a clean break with that kind of stuff is often very difficult for Christians, even when we acknowledge that the associations are evil. See, we know in our head, but we’re drawn to them still emotionally, right? And so it’s hard for us to just, and sometimes that comes out in our music choices.
Well, it’ll be better if we just do a Christian version. That’s what leads us there, but here’s the truth, and you don’t have to believe me. Listen, you don’t have to believe me. I don’t have a Bible verse that proves this, that I can say, a text verse that says, see, this is what happened. But I want to tell you, I know personally examples where the Christian version of certain styles of music was the bridge that got this person to revert back to what was not Christian at all.
Not even in words. It’s a segue. And it’s dangerous. It’s dangerous. I’ve seen it happen. You’re not going to convince me otherwise. I’ve seen it happen. And some of you have seen it happen. So that’s why you’ve got to be careful with music. Because it will become a bridge back to sin. And to a life that is not pleasing to God. And that’s just a fact of it.
But the question as far as our difficulty in making a clean break with styles of music is a question of whether we’re willing to make a hard break with those things for Christ’s sake when we see they are evil. When we see the associations are evil, are we willing for the sake of the Lord Jesus Christ to say, I’m done. I’m done. You see, a secret love for that music makes us very reluctant to forsake it.
A secret love. Now, I want to ask you a question before we move to Ephesians. Some of you, this is not going to make any sense to you. Others of you are going to know exactly what I’m talking about. Some of you could probably give me examples from your era that I’m not familiar with that would also apply. But you think about, those of you that are familiar with these things, headbanging.
Headbanging. That’s okay. Some of you are like, how many of you have no idea what I just said? Okay, that’s fine. That’s fine. How many of you do know what I just said? It’s about half and half. Mosh pit. Thug life. I mentioned that a minute ago. These are things associated with different styles of music. Are these things spiritual? They are done in the name of Christ all the time.
At concerts, they’re done in the name of Christ. Are they associated with anything good? No. So the idea that music is all moral often translates into the idea, listen carefully now, it translates into the idea that this kind of music is also all moral. And then the associations and the products of that kind of music are also justified. So for those of you that don’t know, a mosh pit is something that they do at rock concerts where they form a ring and basically run into each other.
It’s absolutely as retarded as it sounds. And we’re going to have a mosh pit for Jesus. And I know that’s an extreme kind of crazy example, but there are absolutely people that engage in this and argue for it. So I’m being realistic in what I say. Those associations should be the things that are used to judge the music by Scripture. Okay. Now let me hasten to say this, and this is important for us to get.
When you are making a judgment on styles of music and their associations, you have to acknowledge, and I have to acknowledge, that every one of us will judge it somewhat differently from one another. Because it is a judgment. It is the application of scriptural truth to certain associations that you have within your perspective. And that might be a little different than others. But the key thing, the Lord allows for that, by the way.
Latitude, spiritual latitude, He allows for that. So long as we are honestly applying the scripture to it. And anything that the Lord puts His finger on using the scripture, we’re willing to cut that thing off. Right? Now that might look a little bit different in each one of us, but generally speaking, we’ll be all going in the same direction. Okay. Now let’s go to Ephesians chapter 5.
Ephesians chapter 5. And as well, if you will, get Colossians chapter 3. This is a parallel passage. Ephesians 5 and Colossians 3. Ephesians chapter 5 verse number 19. You’re very familiar with this. This is speaking of verse 18 says, And be not drunk with wine, wherein is excess, but be filled with the Spirit. So the imperative, the command here is be filled with the Spirit. And verse 19 says, Speaking to yourselves in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, which is describing how you’re filled with the Spirit or characteristics of one who is filled with the Spirit.
But notice it says, Speaking to yourselves in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing, that means using your voice, and making melody in your heart to the Lord. Okay? Psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs. Now look at Colossians chapter 3, verse number 16. It says this, Now, in both verses, there are three categories, if you will, Psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs. Now, the first is psalms. This is the same word, obviously, that is used to refer to the book of Scripture that is made up of psalms.
Let’s look at an example of that. Look at Luke chapter 20. Luke chapter So the word psalm is a very difficult word to define. 20. Luke chapter 20, verse 42. Did you know that? The only way it’s used is to refer to the book of Psalms. That’s it. In Hebrew, that’s the way it is. In English, that’s the way it is. It only refers to the book of Psalms.
So when the Bible is referring to speaking to yourselves in Psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, Psalms are specifically singing the Psalms. Singing God’s very word, which the Psalms are. That’s what the Hebrews would do. They would sing, they would put the Psalms, which are poetry, to music in the same way that we do, except that their poetry was inspired by God. It was God’s Word. Unlike our hymn book is not, but theirs was.
The book of Psalms. So you have the Psalms. So singing God’s Word. The second one is hymns. If you will look at Matthew 26, Matthew chapter 26, verse 30. At the end of the first Lord’s Supper, verse 30 but that the text is not from Scripture. They’re non-Scriptural songs that give praise to God. We have many of them in, obviously, our hymn book. says this, Not that they’re not consistent with Scripture, And then the third one is spiritual songs.
And really, this is where the third one is really where the rubber meets the road in our study here. Spiritual songs. Spiritual songs can encompass all other kinds of songs that are not direct praise to God, but deal with spiritual or scriptural themes. Okay? So, we have a lot, we have a number of songs that are like that, that are not intended to be sung to God, but about the Lord or about some spiritual experience or like saved by the blood of the crucified one.
That’s not an ode or a hymn to God like, give me one, holy, holy, holy or oh for a thousand tongues to sing or something like that. But it does deal with the spiritual scriptural theme. Okay, and that’s obviously permitted in Scripture. Okay. But what I want you to see, Colossians, go back to Colossians 3 if you would. This is an important part of our music for Choice Hills Baptist Church.
And I’ll get real practical here in a minute, but Colossians 3.16, once again, we’ll read it. It says this, Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly in all wisdom, teaching and admonishing one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs. Now that tells us that the Word of Christ is supposed to be part of our music. Alright, so let me apply that. That means our music should contain the Word of Christ.
Our music should teach the church. That’s what it says in verse 16. Our music should admonish the church. Right? Encourage the church to do what the Lord says. Our music is a biblical expression of praise to God. That’s in both verses as well. Singing with grace in your hearts to the Lord. Now, if that’s true and the Word of Christ is supposed to be kind of the content, at least the content and lyric of our music, that means our music should be thoroughly scriptural.
Now be careful here. It should be scriptural. Not everything that we sing is scriptural. Not everything we sing is consistent with the Bible. It might give us the feels. It might be something we’ve sung forever. But that doesn’t mean it’s scriptural. And it’s supposed to be scriptural, the Word of Christ. It’s supposed to be consistent with His Word. And this is true not only of, you know, kind of the Stamps-Baxter era, the 50s era, you know, kind of that style, but also true of older from the 1700s and 1800s.
It’s likewise true. So we should do our best to make sure that the songs that we sing are scriptural. That is the first concern, that they are scriptural. Because songs teach us. That’s what this verse is telling us. So that just like the preacher or the teacher in the class is supposed to teach you what the Bible says, so the songs are supposed to reaffirm that because it’s an avenue of teaching.
Now go back to Ephesians, if you would. Chapter 5. I’ll just be able to introduce this briefly, but Ephesians 5, verse 19. Speaking to yourselves in psalms and hymns, and notice what it says, spiritual psalms songs. Now I think one mistake we make, and this is so common in so many verses of Scripture, but one of the mistakes we make is we read spiritual songs and basically we identify that, those two words, as the name of a genre of music.
I don’t think that’s right. I don’t think this is saying you have, you know, rock, rap, spiritual songs. I don’t think that’s what it’s saying. What I think is, I think it’s saying songs that are spiritual. Okay? Songs are, I mean, I know that’s profound. That’s profound. I’ll send you my doctorate, you know. It’s profound. Now, what does it mean to be spiritual? See, that, again, the reason why I think it’s a mistake to say, well, that’s just referring to a genre of music that has spiritual themes or a genre of music that is about the Bible or whatever, salvation. Well, that could include Christian rap and that could include whatever.
But in Scripture, there isn’t a genre like that. It’s not a name. It’s describing the song. The song is spiritual. And that has a very narrow definition in Scripture. What is the opposite of spiritual? Everybody knows that. Carnal. Okay. That sheds a little light. What is a carnal song? Okay. Just by contrast. What’s a carnal song? No, no. I don’t want a genre. I don’t want a genre.
Although that might apply. Huh? Okay. What else? The flesh. Exactly. It’s the opposite of spiritual song is a carnal song. And a carnal song is one that appeals to, motivates, stirs up, and in any other way is associated with, key word here, what the scripture identifies as the flesh. Now, here we come full circle to the associations of the music. Because whatever the scriptures identify as associated with the flesh, we’ll have to do this next week in Galatians, which we will look at.
Those things, those associations are what make scripturally those styles music that is not spiritual. Because those, I’ll just give you an example really quick. Okay. Drug use and drunkenness. Those are clearly associated with certain styles of music. Hip-hop as an example. Okay. When you go to Galatians chapter 5, you can identify those things associated with the flesh, with carnality. And therefore, it is in violation of Ephesians chapter 5 verse 19 because it says spiritual songs, not carnal songs.
And the reverse is true as well. Those things that are associated with spirituality, that is the Spirit of God, as defined in Galatians 5, tell us the kinds of associations in music that are godly. Right? So when the Lord says, these are spiritual songs you should sing, it should stir the spirit, the spirit of God, not the carnal part of us. And that’s really where the rubber meets the road, where it gets down to the brass tacks of practice.
We have to be honest and look at our music and say, what does this stir in me? What does it produce in me? And there you will often have your answer. You will often have your answer. Alright, let’s pause there. Let’s pray together.